The Importance of Dates in Your Insurance Policy

The importance of dates in your insurance policy is critical. There are three specifically that are often confused with each other but are highly crucial in insurance litigation. And to make it more befuddling, insurance companies each have their own definitions of those terms in their policies which they are supposed to follow. The three terms are issue date, policy date, and effective date. We will give you the generally understood meaning of these terms.

Inception Date vs Effective Date

The policy start date is normally the date on which the insurance company approves and accepts your application. The policy date is the date written on the policy. These two are sometimes the same, but insurance companies often add a few days to the issue date to name a policy date. This allows time for the policy to be delivered to the insured. The effective date is the date on which the legal obligation by the insurance company is created.

This is significant because it is the date on which the insurance company becomes liable under the contract. Insurance companies usually try to make the effective date very clear in their policies and define it in the policy and the application. The date on which a policy first takes effect is determined by several factors, such as whether a premium was paid with the application and if a conditional receipt was given for the premium if a premium was paid.

Almost all applications read that coverage is not effective until the policy is delivered, and the first premium is paid. Therefore, these criteria must be met before the policy is considered to be in place. Backdating a policy usually results in different issues and effective dates. In that circumstance, premium due dates are ordinarily computed from the date of issue, while contestable and suicide periods run from the effective date. The effective date under a conditional receipt depends on the language of the receipt and state law.

This is a very complicated area of the law and courts apply different legal theories, depending on the facts and circumstances of each case. To give you a few examples, one court determined that a suicide period in a life insurance policy ran from the date the policy was issued and not from the date of the conditional receipt, because the court considered the policy and the receipt to be two separate contracts. If the date of the conditional receipt had applied, the suicide period would have expired and the insurance company could not have used it as a defense and would have had to pay the death benefit. However, because the two-year suicide exclusion ran from the policy date (also the issue date in this case), the court determined that the insurance company had properly denied the claim.

In another case, the court held that coverage began when the insured first paid his premium and not on a later date defined in the policy because that was what the insured could reasonably have expected (in legal parlance, called the doctrine of reasonable expectation). The policy excluded death from suicide within two years of the effective date of coverage, and the insured committed suicide more than two years after the first premium was paid but less than two years from the coverage date.

Case Studies: The Importance of Dates in Your Insurance Policy

Case Study 1: Delayed Policy Delivery

John applied for a life insurance policy on May 1, 2023. The insurance company approved his application and assigned an issue date of May 5, 2023. However, due to administrative delays, the policy was not delivered to John until May 15, 2023. The policy date was indicated as May 10, 2023, which added a few days from the issue date to account for delivery time. The effective date of the policy was determined as May 10, 2023.

The delay in policy delivery created confusion regarding the start of coverage. John believed his coverage began on May 5, the issue date, while the insurance company argued it started on May 10, the policy date. This discrepancy affected premium due dates and the application of certain policy provisions. John sought legal advice to resolve the issue and clarify the effective date of his coverage.

Case Study 2: Contestable Period Calculation

Sarah purchased a health insurance policy with a start date of January 1, 2023. The policy explicitly stated that coverage would only become effective once the first premium was paid. Sarah submitted her premium payment on January 5, 2023. The insurance company acknowledged receipt of the payment and confirmed that coverage would commence on January 5, 2023.

Unfortunately, Sarah experienced a significant medical issue shortly after obtaining the policy. The insurance company denied her claim, citing the contestable period provision that stated any claims made within the first 30 days of coverage would be subject to additional scrutiny. Sarah contested the denial, arguing that since she paid the premium on January 5, she should be considered covered from that date, and the contestable period should run from that point forward.

This demonstrates the importance of understanding the specific terms and conditions related to the effective date and contestable periods within an insurance policy. Sarah’s legal representation would need to analyze the policy language, state laws, and previous court rulings to determine the validity of her claim.

Case Study 3: Conditional Receipt and Coverage Start

Michael applied for auto insurance on June 1, 2023, and paid the premium on the same day. He received a conditional receipt indicating that coverage would be effective immediately, subject to underwriting approval. The insurance company’s underwriting process took longer than expected, and they approved Michael’s application on June 10, 2023. The policy’s effective date was set as June 10, 2023.

Unfortunately, Michael was involved in a car accident on June 5, 2023, before the underwriting approval and the assigned effective date. The insurance company denied his claim, arguing that the coverage was not yet in force at the time of the accident. Michael sought legal advice to challenge the denial based on the language of the conditional receipt, which indicated immediate coverage upon payment of the premium.

This highlights the potential conflicts that can arise when interpreting the effective date based on conditional receipts and underwriting approval. Resolving such disputes may require a thorough analysis of the policy, the receipt language, and applicable state laws.

The Importance of Dates in Your Insurance Policy: Bottom Line

As you can see, if determining the date from which to begin counting a particular time period is critical to your outcome, you would be well advised to seek the advice of an attorney. There are policy definitional issues, state law issues, and judicial interpretation issues, all of which call for expert legal guidance. It is not an area for a novice.