Was it negligent for my doctor to give a pre-diagnosis of cancer before eliminating other possible causes of my illness first?

Question Details:

My primary doctor pre-diagnosed me with having cancer and referred me to a specialist before finding out if the acne antibiotic that she put me on 3 months earlier could've been the cause for my low white blood cell count. I'd just gotten normal blood test results 3 months earlier during my yearly physical and I do not have a history of health issues. I later found out from my pharmacist that the antibiotic I was taking causes neutropenia (having low WBC), which was my diagnoses in the end. Was is negligent for this doctor to pre-diagnose cancer without looking into the medication first?

Asked 8/4/2011 under Medical Malpractice | 102 View(s) | More Legal Topics

Are you an attorney? Sign up to answer this question.

Medical Malpractice Law Answers

It *may* have been negligent--the issue is what would a "reasonable doctor" do in that situation? If the average well-trained reasonable doctor might have referred you directly to a specialist, then it's not negligent or malpractice. There are valid reasons, by the way, for doing so, so it is unlikely that this was malpractice: for example, with cancer, time is often of the essence; a delay in treatment can be a death sentence. It is often the better practice, if cancer is suspected, to immediately send someone for further evaluation, screening, or treatment, on the grounds that the "damage" done by unnecessary follow-up is much less than the damage done if cancer is ignored and takes further hold. Also, even if it was negligent, the most you could recover in a lawsuit, if you were not actually injured or sickened by being sent to the specialist, would be whatever out-of-pocket medical costs you incurred from the unnecessary treatment.

Related Medical Malpractice Questions

Didn't find your answer? Ask.

AttorneyPages.com

  Top Ranking Attorneys

Sign Up Today! Are you a lawyer?
Want to be featured here?
Sign up for a free profile and get started today! Click Here

More Questions Like This...