What to do if a manufacturer will not honor "lifetime" warranty?
I paid an up-charge for a manufacturers "lifetime warranty". When I called to have a broken fan replaced, I was informed that they no longer honor the warranty past 1 year. Is this legal in CA?
You could sue the manufacturer for breach of contract and specifically breach of express warranty. As a "lifetime" warranty it is not limited to a year. In addition to a cause of action (claim) in your lawsuit for breach of express warranty, you may have a claim for breach of implied warranty of merchantability. The implied warranty of merchantability means that the fan has to be of a quality acceptable in the trade. Another type of implied warranty is the implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose. Since you did use the fan for a year, it may be difficult to claim that there was a breach of the implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose if the fan was functioning properly.
It is also possible that you may have a claim for fraud since the company's "lifetime" warranty is only honored for a year. Fraud is the intentional misrepresentation of a material fact made with knowledge of its falsity and with the intent to induce reliance on which you justifiably relied to your detriment. Your argument supporting a claim of fraud is that you paid for a lifetime warranty which the company intentionally misrepresented to you and is now claiming that it is only a one year warranty. You justifiably relied on a lifetime warranty to your detriment by paying the additional charge for that warranty.