Is it legal for a lender to hold out on an accepted agreement for a short sale?
Question Details:
CALHFA agreed on the purchase price of $279,000 for a short sale. After 7 months, the appraisal was conducted, and they counter-offered me at $289,000 and buyer and seller agreed, addendum signed. It has now been 4 weeks since the offer was accepted. CALHFA responds, "Your counter has been submitted for review." Is this legal?
Yes, unfortunately they can. There is no legal obligation to consent to a short sale--it is completely voluntary. Being voluntary, they can take as long as they want or put any conditions on it. One common condition is to subject any proposed transaction a new review, if any of the conditions change. You indicated that the price was countered; that means that it was a new offer that was put in. Since it was a new offer, CALHFA can review it anew. And again: they may turn it down for any reason at all.

Are you a lawyer?
![]() |